Best Food at Sheetz – The Official MTO Guide

When I think of the good old days, I think of walking to Sheetz slightly impaired at 3 a.m. and grabbing some delicious food. The point is, if anyone can talk about the Sheetz menu, it’s me. In this article we’re going to discuss the best food at Sheetz.

Related Content: How Does Sheetz Curbside Pickup Work?

If you think the Sheetz MTO feature was cool now, imagine how cool it was 20 years ago. We didn’t even have iPhones yet, but we were able to stumble up to a screen, touch a few delicious-looking images and a few minutes later we are munching on said delicious images. Amazing!

The Sheetz App

Since we didn’t have iPhones (or Androids) we obviously weren’t yet introduced to the Sheetz mobile app. If you are a regular at Sheetz, you MUST add this to your arsenal. Take advantage of Sheetz rewards, find awesome promotional offers and most importantly you can achieve your lifelong dream of becoming a Sheetz Freak. And when you make it to Sheetz Freak status, they even reward you with a gift the next time you go into the store.

Okay, it’s time to get into the best food at Sheetz.

Best Sheetz Breakfast Items

Let’s give breakfast its own category. Even though you can order breakfast 24×7 at Sheetz, we’re going to make it its own category.

Sheetz Breakfast Sandwich

The Shmiscuit has always been my go-to. Shmiscuit is how you say biscuit is Sheetzian. Get it with sausage, bacon, ham, steak or chicken sausage. Of course you can have egg (scrambled, fried or white) and then cheese and any other topping you would reasonably want on a sandwich. I like to keep it simple. Bacon, egg and cheese. That’s not to say I haven’t went nuts and loaded this baby up with guacamole, caramelized onion and salsa before. Or you can replicate the McGriddles and go sausage, egg and maple syrup.

Read also  Sheetz Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich - Gas Station Eats!

I chose the Schmiscuit, because I am a biscuit guy. I’ll take it every day of the week over the other bread options. But if you’re not, you’re still covered. The other options for Sheetz breakfast sandwiches are:

  • Shmagel
  • Everything Shmagelz
  • Shmuffin
  • Croissant
  • Sourdough
  • Flatbread
  • Waffle
  • Subs (that’s right, breakfast subs)
  • Quesadillas

Even though I’m a Schmiscuit guy, everyone has to try the breakfast sandwich composed of waffles at least once.

Sheetz Breakfast Sides

My top choice is the mini hashbrowns. Anyone ever had a bad hashbrown? Me either.

Here are the other options:

  • Cinnapocketz (By Cinnabon)
  • French Toast Sticks (YUM)
  • Totz
  • Cheesy Bacon Tater Bombs

Sheetz Breakfast Platter

Pick a meat (sausage, bacon, ham, steak or chicken sausage), pick your bread (bagel, biscuit, croissant, English muffin, sourdough, everything bagel or waffle) and choose a side(mini hashbrowns or tots). You also get to choose toppings, spreads and dippers. Your basic breakfast platter. Can’t go wrong with these.

Best Sheetz Not Breakfast Food

Okay, now it’s time for the main event. Breakfast food is good, but my favorite stuff is not part of the breakfast menu. Let’s go!

Best MTO at Sheetz

The best food MTO at Sheetz is the steak burrito, in my humble opinion. I top mine with cheddar cheese, rice and beans, salsa, sour cream and taco sauce. The taco sauce comes in a packet. I usually put 2-3 packets in there.

Choosing this as my favorite was not an easy call. Let’s go over some of the delicious options that were in consideration.

Sheetz Chicken Sandwich

Even Sheetz got sucked into the Chicken Sandwich Wars. It’s your standard chicken sandwich like they have at Chick-fil-A or Popeyes. Not quite as good, but still a very strong option. And of course, since it’s Sheetz you can top your sandwich with anything you’d like.

Read also  Why is Sheetz Better Than Wawa?

Sheetz Subs, Sandwiches and Wraps

There’s every type of sub you would expect. Chicken, steak, turkey, pizza and more. You can have them toasted and you can find just about any topping you’d like. These are an excellent option.

Sheetz Pizza

The personal pan pizzas at Sheetz are an awesome option. If you’d never had one you should get one today.

Sheetz Burgers

A good friend of mine sold me on trying one of these burgers. He said it’s the best burger he’s ever had. While I would never consider going that far, it’s definitely a solid burger, especially when you consider you got it at a gas station.

Also, I made a video where I went over my experience with the Sheetz burger.

Fried Apps

There are plenty of delicious fried apps at Sheetz. Chicken strips, boneless bites, chicken sliders, curly fryz, fried pickle chips and more. The apps section is something definitely worth checking out in the Sheetz app.

And I made a video featuring some of my favorites!

The Rest of the Menu

There are still some items I did not cover just because there are so many options available. Some of these include:

  • Mac and Cheese
  • Salads
  • Hot Dogs (more on that later)
  • French Toast Sticks

There’s something for everyone at Sheetz. Remember, there’s two people in this world: people who know Sheetz has the best gas station food and those who have only had Wawa. Trust me.

Best Value at Sheetz

To me, this one is a no-brainer. The best value food item at Sheetz is the 2/$1 hot dogs. This includes the basic toppings. No chili or cheese. I generally go mustard or mustard and relish. No ketchup for me on a hot dog, since I am not a psycho. If you’re really hungry bump it up to four hot dogs. Not many ways out there to fill up on $2.

Read also  When Does Sheetz Stop Serving Food?

Adding chili is .45 cents per dog and cheese is .50. So two hot dogs with mustard, chili and onion are $1.90. That is a deal!

Sheetz Milkshakes

Sheetz milkshakes are incredible. There are so many options to go with. From Oreos to Reese’s Peanut Butter to every other flavor you could imagine. If you’re looking for something sweet, a milkshake is definitely a great option.

There are other MTO drink options including coffee, lattes, smoothies and more. These are definitely worth a look.

Limited-Time Items

A lot of items come and go at Sheetz. Some of these include deep fried oreos, Nashville Chicken Sandwich and many others. Keep your eyes open in the app because these come and go and some of them are seriously good!

Here’s a video I made featuring the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich:

What Happened to the Sheetz Special Request Button?

This is for the old-school Sheetz Freaks out there. Back in the day when you ordered in the store at the touch screen, you were able to hit a “Special Request” button and one of the Sheetz workers would come up and ask you about it when I got a moment.

A moment of silence for the Sheetz Special Request Button


In closing, I want to say that Sheetz is the best gas station food option there is. The food is delicious, there’s an incredible variety of options and the prices are very reasonable. If you’ve never been to one, I urge you to check it out the next time you see one on a road trip. You will not be let down.